Adjoint inversion of the thermal structure of Southeastern Australia

Aug 16, 2019·
Dr. Ben Mather
Dr. Ben Mather
Louis Moresi
Louis Moresi
Peter Rayner
Peter Rayner
· 2 min read
Model with the optimal tradeoff between Curie depth, heat flow data and a priori estimates of thermal conductivity and rates of heat production.
Abstract
The variation of temperature in the crust is difficult to quantify due to the sparsity of surface heat flow observations and lack of measurements on the thermal properties of rocks at depth. We examine the degree to which the thermal structure of the crust can be constrained from Curie depth and surface heat flow data in Southeastern Australia. We cast the inverse problem of heat conduction within a Bayesian framework and derive its adjoint so we can efficiently find the optimal model that best reproduces the data and prior information on the thermal properties of the crust. Efficiency gains obtained from the adjoint method facilitates a detailed exploration of thermal structure in SE Australia, where we predict high temperatures within Precambrian rocks of 650°C due to relatively high rates of heat production (0.9–1.4μW/m³). In contrast, temperatures within dominantly Phanerozoic crust reach only 520°C at the Moho due to the low rates of heat production in Cambrian mafic volcanics. A combination of Curie depth and heat flow data are required to constrain the uncertainty of lower crustal temperatures to ± 73°C. We also show that parts of the crust are unconstrained if either dataset is omitted from the inversion.
Type
Publication
Geophysical Journal International
publications

Modelling temperature in the Earth’s crust is accomplished by populating a geological model with thermal properties, such as thermal conductivity and rates of heat production, and solving a numerical model of thermal diffusion with assigned boundary conditions. The desired temperature solution is often the one that best matches our observations – e.g. temperature in a well – but strong assumptions are made of how thermal properties vary with depth, which result in simple first-order predictions of the temperature field.

Posing an inverse problem is a way to ascertain how much your observations tells you about a particular model. Finding better and better solutions usually require running model after model with slight changes in the input parameters to find a better fit to the observations. For instance, a lower rate of heat production in one layer of the Earth’s crust may result in a better match to an observation of heat flow coming out of the ground. This is fine if the number of unknowns is small, but when we start to increase the quantity of unknown parameters then it takes an exponentially long time to find the model that best reproduces our observations.

In this paper, we formulate a novel inversion method that uses the gradient to quickly find the optimal configuration of thermal properties that best match our observations. We publish improved estimates of the thermal state of the crust in Victoria using heat flow measurements and Curie depth in a joint inversion using 3D geological models, and numerical models of thermal diffusion. The outcome of this work is an estimation of basal heat flux, thermal properties, and the rate of heat production for various domains in the model together with uncertainty information.

Dr. Ben Mather
Authors
ARC Industry Research Fellow

I am an ARC Industry Research Fellow in the School of Geography, Earth and Atmospheric Sciences at The University of Melbourne. I am an expert in fusing Earth evolution models with data to understand how groundwater moves critical minerals through the landscape. Related research interests include the cycling of volatiles within the Earth, probabilistic thermal models of the lithosphere to unravel past tectonic and climatic events, and understanding the how enigmatic volcanoes form.

I am a vocal advocate for the integral role of geoscience in responding to challenges we face in transitioning to the carbon-neutral economy. As an expert in my field, I have been interviewed in national and international print media, TV, and radio on a wide variety of subjects including earthquakes, volcanoes, groundwater, and critical minerals.

Louis Moresi
Authors
Professor of Computational Mathematics & Geophysics
Louis Moresi specialises in computational geodynamics, developing the Underworld software to model mantle convection, lithospheric deformation, and plate tectonics. He is a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science and the American Geophysical Union.
Peter Rayner
Authors
Professor
Peter Rayner uses satellite and in-situ measurements combined with inverse modelling to estimate surface sources and sinks of CO2.