Determining subsurface temperature & lithospheric structure from joint geophysical-petrological inversion: A case study from Ireland

Dec 1, 2023·
Emma L. Chambers
Emma L. Chambers
Raffaele Bonadio
Raffaele Bonadio
Javier Fullea
Javier Fullea
Sergei Lebedev
Sergei Lebedev
Yihe Xu
Yihe Xu
Duygu Kiyan
Duygu Kiyan
Christopher J. Bean
Christopher J. Bean
Patrick A. Meere
Patrick A. Meere
Dr. Ben Mather
Dr. Ben Mather
Brian M. O'Reilly
Brian M. O'Reilly
· 1 min read
Abstract
High quality maps of the geothermal gradient and temperature are essential when assessing geothermal potential for a region. However, determining geothermal potential is a challenge as direct measurements of in situ temperature are sparse and individual geophysical methods are sensitive to a range of parameters, not solely temperature. Here, we develop a novel approach to determine the geothermal gradient using a new joint geophysical-petrological inversion where seismic velocities and density in the mantle are related to temperature and bulk composition within a thermodynamic framework. Large datasets of phase velocities of seismic surface-waves are now incorporated into the inversion, and provide essential constraints on the lithospheric thickness and temperature, which shape the crustal geotherms to a significant extent. We also include all available measurements of the surface heat flow, radiogenic heat production (RHP) and thermal conductivity within the crust, to further constrain the temperature and geothermal gradient. We use Ireland as a case study and show how our new methodology can reproduce the results of previous work but also improve on them, thanks to the complementary sensitivities of the full range of data.
Type
Publication
Tectonophysics
publications

Plain Language Summary

Understanding the temperature deep underground is critical for assessing whether a region could be used for geothermal energy — a clean, renewable energy source. However, direct temperature measurements from boreholes are rare and expensive, so scientists need indirect methods to estimate subsurface temperatures over wide areas.

This study develops a new approach that combines multiple types of geophysical data — including seismic wave speeds, gravity measurements, surface heat flow, and rock property measurements — within a single computational framework. By jointly inverting all of these datasets together, the method produces more reliable maps of underground temperature and the structure of the Earth’s outer layer (the lithosphere) than any single dataset could provide alone.

Applied to Ireland as a test case, the results show that the thickness of the lithosphere and the crust are the primary controls on the geothermal gradient, with thinner lithosphere areas showing higher temperatures closer to the surface. In some locations, rocks rich in radioactive elements generate extra heat that boosts the geothermal gradient locally. This methodology can be applied to any region with limited direct temperature data, helping to identify promising areas for geothermal energy development.

Emma L. Chambers
Authors
Postdoctoral Research Fellow
Emma Chambers specialises in seismic imaging and joint geophysical-petrological inversion to determine subsurface temperature structure and geothermal potential.
Raffaele Bonadio
Authors
Research Associate
Raffaele Bonadio studies the structure and evolution of the lithosphere using seismic tomography and surface wave analysis.
Javier Fullea
Authors
Professor of Geophysics
Javier Fullea specialises in integrated geophysical-petrological modelling of the lithosphere and upper mantle. He is a key developer of the LitMod software for 3D lithospheric imaging and the WINTERC-G global thermochemical model.
Sergei Lebedev
Authors
Professor of Geophysics
Sergei Lebedev develops and applies seismic tomography methods to image Earth’s lithospheric and mantle structure, spanning mantle dynamics and tectonic plate thickness variations.
Yihe Xu
Authors
Research Associate
Yihe Xu works on global seismology, including seismic wave propagation, anisotropy, and borehole seismic methods.
Duygu Kiyan
Authors
Schrodinger Research Fellow
Duygu Kiyan applies magnetotelluric methods to image crustal and lithospheric structure for deep geothermal resource assessment and volcanic system investigations.
Christopher J. Bean
Authors
Senior Professor and Head of Geophysics
Christopher Bean’s research focuses on volcano seismology, seismic wave propagation, and microseism sources, with applications to earthquake hazard prediction.
Patrick A. Meere
Authors
Senior Lecturer in Geology
Patrick Meere is a structural geologist who studies fluid flow in faults and vein systems, with focus on metalliferous ore emplacement and Variscan deformation.
Dr. Ben Mather
Authors
ARC Industry Research Fellow

I am an ARC Industry Research Fellow in the School of Geography, Earth and Atmospheric Sciences at The University of Melbourne. I am an expert in fusing Earth evolution models with data to understand how groundwater moves critical minerals through the landscape. Related research interests include the cycling of volatiles within the Earth, probabilistic thermal models of the lithosphere to unravel past tectonic and climatic events, and understanding the how enigmatic volcanoes form.

I am a vocal advocate for the integral role of geoscience in responding to challenges we face in transitioning to the carbon-neutral economy. As an expert in my field, I have been interviewed in national and international print media, TV, and radio on a wide variety of subjects including earthquakes, volcanoes, groundwater, and critical minerals.

Brian M. O'Reilly
Authors
Assistant Professor
Brian O’Reilly is a marine geophysicist whose research focuses on the lithospheric structure of continents and the development of continental margins in the North Atlantic.